Supergirl, Wonder Woman, and Batgirl all on the same kids t-shirt. As a geek dad it’s the kind of item I’m always on the lookout for. I don’t even mind (too much) that it’s pink. What’s troubling is the slogan, “Girls Rule!”. Because “Girls” don’t rule at all.
It’s a phrase synonymous with “Girl Power”, which probably has its origins in the Riot Grrrl feminist punk movement of the 90’s. While the progressive message of “Grrrl Power” was diluted when transformed into the safe and snappy commercial slogan “Girl Power” for 90’s pop phenomenon the Spice Girls, at least that version introduced many children to the notion of girl empowerment. However, the band also popularised the far more problematic “Girls Rule!”.
The girls who were fans of the band in the 90’s are now women in their twenties and thirties. What kind of world have they grown up in? Is it one where “Girls Rule”? The gender pay gap remains entrenched, and in the UK is even widening. Only 30% of science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) graduates in the UK are women, and just 17% of all professors in STEM are female. Both houses of UK parliament have only 23% women.
Globally, while there are high profile women in leadership roles at a corporate level, boards and executive committees remain 83%-96% male. The recent IMF report Fair Play: More Equal Laws Boost Female Labor Force Participation found that 90% of countries have at least one important gender based legal restriction. The UNDP states that “Gender inequality remains a major barrier to human development.”
A slogan like “Girls Rule” seems little more than a lie in this context. It implies that women leaders are respected, listened to, and rewarded for their hard work, talent, and intelligence – when that is clearly not the case. Perhaps the slogan “Girls Rule!” was created as a way of hiding the sad reality of gender inequality.
The empowering messages we convey to our children are important, but they can easily backfire. As American comedian Sarah Silverman wryly observed, “Don’t tell girls they can be anything they want when they grow up. Because it would have never occurred to them that they couldn’t.”
Recent research on marketing to girls found that when “…girls hit the age of 13 they start to feel less confident and more worried about the world around them.” The reasons are unclear, but this would also be the time they experience the dawning revelation that the reality of being a woman, on the wrong side of the gender bias divide, isn’t quite how they imagined it would be when they were little girls.
Advertisers obviously know the power of a good slogan, and a source for a new girl empowerment one has come from an unlikely place. Always (makers of ‘feminine hygiene products’) found through their market research the same issue of girls suffering a significant drop in self-confidence around the time they hit puberty.
The company tried to address these feelings for an ad campaign, and a new slogan entered the girl empowerment lexicon – #LikeAGirl. They deftly took the former playground insult, and transformed it into plaudit. When you run like a girl, throw like a girl, fight like a girl – you are not doing it badly, you’re doing it incredibly. At least that’s the shift in meaning hoped for.
The fantasy of “Girls Rule!” seems tepid next to the optimistic reality of doing amazing things ‘like a girl’.
All I need now is to get THAT on a kid’s female superhero t-shirt.
I’m not going to pretend to my daughter that she’s growing up in a world where “Girls Rule”. She will have many challenges to face in life, and lying to her about them won’t help her deal with them.
But I’m buying Asda’s “Girls Rule!” t-shirt for her. Three awesome female superheroes, drawn in the classic retro style, on a kid’s sized top in the UK? Sold. I also want Asda to know that female superheroes sell too.
And my daughter can’t read. Yet.
What do you think about the slogan “Girls Rule”? Helpful, harmful or neither? Please discuss by commenting below, joining the conversation on the Facebook page, or on Twitter @manvspink.
I believe that the “Girls Rule” might date back to the 1980s or even earlier with Lucy Van Pelt from Peanuts. There was a book printed in the 80s called Lucy Rules, OK and there was definitely the Girls Rule motif mentioned in that. Lucy might have been the model for the Girl Power movement of the 90s.
I love that “fly like a girl” slogan, and would work brilliantly on a superhero t-shirt (you need to make and sell them, I’d buy one for my daughter – 5 years old but wears clothes 6-7 if you do make them lol).
I would buy one to my 9 years old boy….or two. Or a dozen for all the girls and boys in his class. He already knows all mums have superpowers but I would love to make it extensive to every girl everywhere…..
I’ll consider those preorders Pepa 😉
Cheers Ashley – I’ll bear that sizing info in mind 😉
Hola
Para gusto los colores dice el dicho.
Tengo 40 años y me encanta el color rosa, de hecho, tengo todos casi en rosa. En cambio, no me agrada para nada los azules, negro y cía.
Mi sobrina que tiene tres añitos, sólo quiere de color Rosa y nadie le impone nada, a su madre la tiene aborrecida con tantos rosas pero quién se la quita.
Interesting perspective, I enjoyed reading this post.
For many this is an issue, but I don’t feel I’ve been hard done by as women. There will always be a fight for equality but I think we should all just concentrate on living life instead of our differences. We’re all right our on battles without fighting our sexualities too.
Remembering the 90’s the “X rule!” was where “rule/rules/rulez” was never meant to be literal, it was just slang and meant X is/are awesome.
For some reason the phrase “Boys Rule” is associated with 1950’s and 60’s little boys having a “no girls allowed” clubhouse or tree house. But this generic “yahoo answers” rings true. Makes the Girls Rule message more problematic.
https://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20100316100121AAMc7Mv
Great article, full of good thoughts.
Hadn’t really thought about ‘Girls Rule’ in that way. Thanks.
I think ‘Girls Rock’ with rock-hand gesture is better.
X
Thanks. There’s no easy answers to this stuff – much of it is a minefield.